April 2025 · Consumer Reports Study

Congratulations — you know
your insurance.

You nailed it. Erie Insurance Group is officially the gold standard for 2025 — and you already knew that.

RUN MY COMPARISON
RUN MY COMPARISON
You Know Your Insurance — Carlson Insurance

✓  Your Answer Was Correct — Erie Insurance Group

#1 out of 36 companies
The National Study

In a survey of 40,000+ policyholders, Erie came out on top.

In a national sample of over 40,000 policyholders, Erie secured the #1 ranking out of 36 companies in Consumer Reports’ latest car insurance study.

Erie outperformed 35 other major providers across claims settlements, breadth of coverage, and policy clarity — the things that actually matter when you need your insurance to show up.

72pts Overall Score
★★★★★ Claims Settlements Perfect 5/5 — Best in Class
#1 Out of 36 companies Coverage & Policy Clarity: 4/5
Why You’re Right
★
Perfect Claims Score Erie earned a perfect 5/5 for claims settlements — the highest rating in the entire study.
✓
Breadth of Coverage They outperformed 35 other major providers on the breadth and clarity of what they actually cover.
72
Top Overall Score Erie’s overall score of 72 leads the pack — the next closest competitor scored 69.
👤
Real Policyholders These ratings come from 40,566 actual U.S. auto insurance customers — not sponsored data.
The Proof

See the full Consumer Reports ranking.

Erie Insurance Consumer Reports.pdf
📄  View Full PDF

Scroll within the document to view the full rankings table — Erie Insurance Group: Overall Score 72, #1 out of 36 companies.

Since You Already Know Who’s Best

Are you curious if you can get better coverage or a better rate?

Since you already know who’s the best, let’s compare your current plan to Erie Insurance and see what you could be saving — or gaining in coverage.

Run My Comparison

Ratings are based on a national sample of 40,566 U.S. adult auto insurance policyholders surveyed by Consumer Reports. Reprinted with permission from Consumer Reports ©2025.