April 2025 · Consumer Reports Study
Great guess, but the #1 spot
might surprise you.
While many big names spend millions on commercials, one company quietly topped the charts for actual customer experience.
The #1 Rated Car Insurance Company is…
🏆 Erie Insurance Group#1 out of 36 companies
They didn’t win on ads.
They won on results.
In the latest national Consumer Reports study, Erie Insurance Group was rated #1 out of 36 top car insurance companies — based on the real experiences of over 40,000 policyholders.
The company you named is well-known, but when it comes to what actually matters — claims settlements, coverage clarity, and overall satisfaction — Erie leads the pack.
See the full Consumer Reports ranking.
Scroll within the document to view the full rankings table — Erie Insurance Group: Overall Score 72, #1 out of 36 companies.
Want to see how your current policy stacks up against the #1 rated provider?
Let us run a quick, no-pressure comparison for you. We’ll look at your current coverage, your rate, and show you exactly where you stand against Erie Insurance.
Run My ComparisonRatings are based on a national sample of 40,566 U.S. adult auto insurance policyholders surveyed by Consumer Reports. Reprinted with permission from Consumer Reports ©2025.